The Supreme Court has granted Zoltan Almasi leave to appeal against his murder conviction, in a determination delivered on 18 February 2020. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave but did not object to an extension of time.
The Court of Appeal affirmed Mr Almasi's conviction in a judgment of 26 July 2018, and its order was perfected on 6 November 2018. His application for leave to appeal was not lodged until 31 October 2019, which was out of time.
The Supreme Court extended the time, so the late application could be considered. It accepted that Mr Almasi was at some personal disadvantage in dealing with the matter, and the respondent did not object.
The Court noted that his current solicitor was instructed in August 2019. It said that where a time limit has been missed, solicitors must make every effort to expedite the application.
The Court found that three points meet the constitutional criteria, as raising issues of general public importance or issues that need to be decided in the interests of justice. The first is whether the Court of Appeal was right to uphold the trial judge's ruling that the partial defence of provocation should not be put before the jury.
The second is whether it was right to uphold the decision allowing the prosecution to edit the memoranda of interview with Mr Almasi. The edits omitted statements made, and the terms of the questions asked, by the investigating gardaí.
The third is whether it was right to uphold the ruling that evidence of the deceased's demeanour and conduct before the event leading to his death was inadmissible.
Leave is granted on the grounds set out in the appendix to the notice of application. The parties are to lodge submissions in the usual way.
The Court noted that another appeal on the law of provocation, Director of Public Prosecutions v McNamara, is listed for hearing on 19 March 2020. If either side thinks that judgment is relevant, it can be raised in the case management process.
The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice Charleton and Justice O'Malley.