localnews.ie

Saheed Adeola Ishola refused Supreme Court appeal over deportation order

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court rejected a direct appeal from his family's failed High Court challenge to a deportation order made against him in August 2019.

The Supreme Court on 17 December 2020 refused Saheed Adeola Ishola, his wife Abisola Nimotalai Ishola and their child leave to appeal directly from the High Court. They had challenged a deportation order against Mr Ishola.

Mr Ishola was convicted in 2012 of a drugs offence over a plan to import more than €1.4 million worth of cocaine. He was sentenced to ten years, with three suspended, and was released early in 2016. The Minister for Justice and Equality made the deportation order in August 2019.

The family argued the Minister failed to protect their rights as a married family under Article 41 of the Constitution. They also said the decision was disproportionate and ignored the time since the offence.

Barrett J refused their challenge on 14 November 2019. He found the Minister had given the case thorough consideration. On 18 February 2020 he refused a certificate to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The family asked the Supreme Court to hear three questions. They related to Article 41 rights, the use of a 2012 conviction and the "insurmountable obstacles" test.

The Minister opposed the application. The court said it could not rule on the merits of whether a 2012 conviction was too old to rely on.

O'Donnell J, McKechnie J and Charleton J said the family's case had "a very specific factual pattern".

The court found no exceptional circumstances to justify an appeal straight from the High Court.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal