localnews.ie

Peter Kenny refused Supreme Court appeal over murder conviction and key witness

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

He argued a trial court should have excluded the evidence of a witness who was himself part of the plot; the court said established law was applied.

The Supreme Court on 17 December 2020 refused Peter Kenny leave to appeal his conviction for the murder of John Carroll, who was shot in a public house in 2009.

The prosecution case at the Central Criminal Court was that Mr Kenny was the pillion passenger on a motorcycle who walked into the pub and fired the shots. He was the only one of four accused convicted after a trial lasting more than fifty days.

The central witness was Joseph O'Brien, who by his own admission was party to the plot. Mr Kenny argued that the trial judge should have excluded his evidence.

The application pointed to a meeting between two gardaí and Mr O'Brien after his arrest. It said nothing was recorded, and that €3,000 taken from him on arrest was handed to his girlfriend before he finished a statement implicating Mr Kenny.

The Director of Public Prosecutions said both courts applied the principles in DPP v Gilligan, as the parties had agreed they should.

The Supreme Court agreed that the trial court and the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles, so no issue of general public importance arose. It said the circumstances did not engage the interests of justice.

The court also commented on delay. Mr Kenny did not ask for the Court of Appeal's order of 20 February 2018 to be perfected until June 2020, which it called "unsatisfactory and undesirable".

The determination was made by Clarke CJ, Dunne J and Baker J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal