The Supreme Court on 15 December 2020 granted James Joseph Cassidy leave to appeal his conviction for membership of an unlawful organisation.
Leave was granted on one issue only. The court refused leave on a second point.
Mr Cassidy was convicted by the Special Criminal Court under section 21 of the Offences Against the State Act 1939.
The Court of Appeal ruled against him on 1 May 2020. He applied to the Supreme Court on 25 August 2020.
The first issue concerns belief evidence from a Chief Superintendent. Under section 3 of the 1939 Act, such evidence is that officer's belief about membership.
The trial court had ruled that some material could not be used to support that belief. The officer may have relied on the same material.
Mr Cassidy asks whether the court could still draw inferences of guilt from his false or misleading answers about that material. He says that would be "double counting".
He says the Court of Appeal erred in fact and law in upholding the admission of the evidence.
The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave. It said the trial court took care to exclude matters arising before his arrest on 21 September 2016.
It said the case turns on its own facts and raises no issue of general public importance.
The Supreme Court was persuaded that the double counting point was made out on the papers. It noted the factual basis must be established in the decisions of both courts.
The second issue alleged objective bias. Mr Cassidy said the Chief Superintendent had discussed the evidence with other officers and "knew a lot" about the investigation.
The court called that ground "unstateable" and "misconceived". It said a Chief Superintendent involved in a prosecution is not a neutral decision-maker.
The court will address what material it needs for the appeal at case management.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, MacMenamin J and Baker J.