Paul Flaherty has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over his conviction for sexual assault. The Court said there is well-established, recent case law on how to treat an unclear jury verdict.
The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 14 February 2020. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed the application.
Mr Flaherty was charged with four counts of rape, sexual assault and making threats to kill. The jury convicted him of sexual assault only. It acquitted him of oral rape and threats to kill and could not agree on a charge of vaginal rape. He received two and a half years, reduced from five.
He argued the verdict was bad for uncertainty, because the acts behind it could not be identified. He also challenged the refusal of a stay on his trial. The Court of Appeal rejected both arguments in judgments of 31 July and 18 October 2019.
The Supreme Court noted that the complaint was that the Court of Appeal's supplemental ruling was "terse". It said the complaint was not that the point went unconsidered.
It found the Court of Appeal had heard further argument, so the issue was confined to the course of this trial. The Court said no issue of general public importance arose and the interests of justice did not warrant leave.
The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice Irvine and Justice Baker.