localnews.ie

Barry Sheehan granted Supreme Court appeal over solicitor misconduct finding

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court granted leave on one issue only: whether the High Court can consider a challenge to a tribunal's jurisdiction in a statutory appeal under the Solicitors Act.

The Supreme Court has granted solicitor Barry Sheehan leave to appeal against a finding of professional misconduct made by the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, in a determination delivered on 15 December 2020. Leave was granted on a single issue.

That issue is the nature of the statutory appeal under the Solicitors Act. The court will consider whether the High Court, and the Court of Appeal on a further appeal, may examine a challenge to the Tribunal's jurisdiction, or whether such a challenge can be brought only by judicial review.

Mr Sheehan argued that the approach taken in the lower courts can force a person to pursue relief through several separate actions. He said this is cumbersome and breaches the right of access to the courts under the Constitution and Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

The dispute arose from his relationship with Bernard Bingham and Viola Bingham. Mr Sheehan had sued them in the Circuit Court for fees he said were due for work in medical negligence proceedings, and claimed a lien over their files. They counterclaimed for professional negligence and breach of contract. On 24 May 2012 the Circuit Court dismissed his action, finding he had not proved his claim, and dismissed the counterclaim.

The Binghams complained to the Tribunal on 15 September 2014, alleging misconduct including threats to destroy their files. Mr Sheehan said the Tribunal was estopped from proceeding because some complaints had been dismissed by the Law Society in 2009. The Tribunal made a finding of professional misconduct on one complaint on 13 May 2016.

Kelly P in the High Court accepted that a jurisdictional objection could not be pursued in a statutory appeal, which envisaged a full rehearing on the merits. The Court of Appeal agreed in a judgment delivered by Costello J on 26 March 2020 and dismissed the appeal.

The Supreme Court said that, so far as Mr Sheehan challenges findings of fact or inferences, no point of general public importance arises and further appeal is not in the interests of justice. It said a point of general public importance does arise on the extent of the High Court's jurisdiction, noting there may be merit in avoiding a multiplicity of proceedings.

The Binghams have not filed a formal response but wrote to the court opposing leave, saying their resources do not stretch to further involvement. The court pointed them to a scheme offering voluntary legal representation. It also granted the Tribunal an extension of time, after its response was filed one day late through inadvertent error.

The issues may be refined at case management. The determination was made by Clarke CJ, Dunne J and Baker J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal