localnews.ie

Ivo Smits granted Supreme Court appeal over European Arrest Warrant surrender

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said the case raises issues about how long a warrant can be left before it is executed and what remedy must exist in the issuing state.

The Supreme Court has granted Ivo Smits leave to appeal directly from the High Court against an order for his surrender under a European Arrest Warrant, in a determination delivered on 20 November 2020.

Mr Smits was sentenced in Latvia to two years in prison on 29 May 2008. The sentence was suspended in full. It was activated on 20 October 2008 because of a breach of those conditions, and an appeal court in Latvia affirmed the activation on 17 December 2008.

The European Arrest Warrant, the document that asks another country to hand over a person, was not issued until 8 June 2015. Mr Smits was arrested in July 2018. In September 2017, with the permission of the Latvian authorities, he married an Irish national.

On 14 July 2020 the High Court, Paul Burns J, dismissed his objections to surrender and made an order for surrender. The order was made on 31 July 2020 and Mr Smits applied to the Supreme Court on 6 August 2020.

He argued that the case raises a point of general public importance. Where a warrant is issued to enforce a prison sentence and a long time passes before it is executed, he asked whether any assessment of proportionality made when it was issued can be overtaken by the passing of time. He also asked whether a court in the issuing state must offer a remedy to reassess the matter, and whether such a remedy must exist where surrender is resisted on the basis of the right to respect for family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. He did not ask the court to refer questions to the Court of Justice of the EU.

The Minister argued that the issues are essentially academic, because the High Court found nothing in his personal circumstances that would come close to permitting an Article 8 argument. The High Court had held that the facts he relied on, including his marriage, his employment and community involvement, and a back problem needing surgery, did not show that surrender would breach his family life rights.

The Supreme Court said the case raises issues of interconnected fact and law. It said the effect of a lapse of time in issuing or sending a warrant, and the obligations of the country executing it, "may require clarification". It added that it could not say with certainty, on the materials available, that the issue is self-evidently academic.

Leave to appeal was granted. The determination was made by O'Donnell J, Charleton J and O'Malley J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal