The Supreme Court has granted Brigid Wilton McDonagh leave to appeal in her case against the Chief Appeals Officer and the Minister for Social Protection, in a determination delivered on 14 October 2020. The appeal will decide whether she had a right of appeal in a social welfare claim.
The practical question is whether people in her position can challenge a welfare decision at all. The Chief Appeals Officer took the view that no appeal was available to her in the circumstances of her case.
Ms McDonagh brought High Court proceedings to establish that an appeal was in fact available on the proper reading of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005, as amended. The Act sets out the review and appeal structure for welfare claims.
Coffey J concluded that no appeal lay. She appealed to the Court of Appeal, which agreed with him and dismissed her appeal on 22 January 2020.
The respondents opposed leave. They said the lower courts had applied well-established principles of statutory interpretation and that the wording of the Act was clear and unambiguous.
The Supreme Court noted that questions of statutory interpretation can meet the constitutional threshold of general public importance, even where well-established principles are being applied. That can be so where the interpretation could affect a significant number of cases.
The judges said the issues raised here are important. Whether an appeal lies in the circumstances of this case could affect many cases, and the entitlement of people to particular social welfare benefits may matter a great deal to the individuals concerned.
Leave to appeal was granted.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, MacMenamin J and Baker J.