Rosas Construtores S.A., Construções Gabriel AS Couto S.A. and Empresa de Construções Amândio Carvalho S.A. were refused leave by the Supreme Court on 14 October 2020 to appeal an order concerning €278,288 lodged as security for costs.
The companies sought to challenge the Court of Appeal’s direction that the full sum be paid out to the workers’ solicitors. The solicitors had undertaken to use any amount exceeding the appeal costs to discharge other outstanding costs orders against the companies.
The companies argued that the Court of Appeal lacked jurisdiction to use security for one set of costs to meet other unpaid costs orders. They said the evidence put the appeal costs at €50,307 and sought an order limiting payment to that amount, with the balance retained in court.
The Supreme Court held that the order was within the Court of Appeal’s inherent jurisdiction. It said there was ample evidence about the companies’ conduct in the wider proceedings and the unpaid costs orders. The Court was not satisfied that the application raised an issue of general public importance, and refused leave to appeal. The refusal decided only whether an appeal could proceed; it did not determine an appeal on its merits.