The Supreme Court on 12 October 2020 refused Byron Jenkins and Adrienne Jenkins leave to appeal directly from the High Court in Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC's claim for possession of their family home.
The claim was based on a mortgage the couple had entered with GE Woodchester Home Loans Ltd, a lender later renamed Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland). On 17 January 2018 Judge O'Sullivan dismissed the claim, finding the company had an insufficient interest in the property.
On 23 July 2018 the High Court allowed Pepper's appeal. Binchy J's order of 31 July 2018 gave the company possession.
The couple applied on 9 April 2019, well out of time. Their first attempt to file was on 20 March 2019. They said they had sought other legal representation before deciding to act for themselves.
They argued that the case raised issues of general public importance about mortgage clauses and EU consumer protection and data protection law. The court said these were not sufficiently particularised, had not been argued in the High Court and did not relate to its decision.
It said that if they were the issues decided in earlier cases, they had already been determined there. It also noted the almost entirely unexplained delay between July 2018 and March 2019.
The court refused leave without formally ruling on the extension of time. The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.