The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Minister for Housing, Planning and Local Government in a case brought by John Casey, in a determination delivered on 8 October 2020. It also granted Mr Casey leave to cross-appeal.
The case turns on whether a licence was valid when the notification requirements of section 21 of the 1933 Act were not met. The High Court held that the failure meant no valid licence had issued. The Minister says the Act is silent on the effect of non-compliance and that clarification is needed.
The Minister, the Minister for State at the Department, Ireland and the Attorney General applied for a direct, or leapfrog, appeal from the High Court order of 7 July 2020 made by Murphy J. The order followed a judgment of 20 May 2020. The application was made on 31 July 2020 and Mr Casey did not oppose it.
The applicants argue that the High Court was wrong on two points: that the failure to notify meant no valid licence had issued, and that the licence application was a "relevant application" under sections 13A, 19A and 21A of the Act, so the notice requirements applied. BioAtlantis Aquamarine Limited is a notice party.
Mr Casey sought leave to cross-appeal on the High Court's finding that, by bringing judicial review under Order 84 of the Rules of the Superior Courts rather than section 21B, he did not have a properly constituted application.
The Supreme Court said each of the three matters raised is of general legal importance and unlikely to benefit from an intermediate appeal to the Court of Appeal. It said it was in the interests of justice to hear the cross-appeal too, because that would allow a fuller consideration of the issues. A separate Court of Appeal hearing on the procedural point would not be a proper use of court resources.
The Minister had asked for a priority hearing. The court said a formal order was not necessary. It expects the case can be heard in the normal course without significant delay if the parties engage constructively.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, MacMenamin J and Baker J.