localnews.ie

Kevin Hannaway granted Supreme Court appeal over surveillance evidence

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court limited leave to the admissibility of surveillance evidence and wants the appeal heard with those of two co-accused if possible.

The Supreme Court has granted Kevin Hannaway leave to appeal against his conviction for providing assistance to an unlawful organisation, in a determination delivered on 30 September 2020. The court will hear the appeal on one question only: whether evidence obtained through surveillance was admissible.

Mr Hannaway applied on 24 July 2020 for leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal. That court, with Edwards J sitting alongside Birmingham P and McCarthy J, upheld his conviction on 6 February 2020. The charge was brought under section 21A of the Offences Against the State Act 1939, as amended.

He was one of five co-accused convicted of either membership of an unlawful organisation or providing assistance to one. The trial took place in the Special Criminal Court and lasted more than 50 days.

Two of the co-accused, Sean Hannaway and Edward O'Brien, had already applied for leave to appeal. In each case the Supreme Court granted leave on a single issue, the admissibility of evidence obtained through surveillance. It had been argued that section 10 of the Criminal Justice (Surveillance) Act 2009 was not complied with. Sean Hannaway's appeal had been fixed for late October.

The judges said the same point arises in Kevin Hannaway's case. They considered it desirable that a party should have the chance to make submissions on a point that could decide the outcome of another party's appeal, rather than wait for that appeal and be bound by it. They added that bringing in extra parties should not lead to arguments being repeated.

Leave was therefore granted strictly on the basis that this case and its companion cases can be advanced to be argued at the same time as the Hannaway and O'Brien appeals, if that is possible. Baker J had already given directions in those appeals and fixed a case management hearing for 14 October. The issue may be refined at that hearing.

Written submissions on each side are limited to 4,000 words. Mr Hannaway's were due by Wednesday 7 October and the respondent's by 12 October. The parties must attend the case management hearing and keep to a strict, limited allocation of time for oral argument.

The determination was made by O'Donnell J, Dunne J and Charleton J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal