David Nooney has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for membership of an unlawful organisation. The determination was delivered on 30 September 2020.
Mr Nooney was one of five people tried together before the Special Criminal Court and convicted of membership of an unlawful organisation or of assisting one. The trial ran for more than 50 days. The Court of Appeal upheld his conviction on 6 February 2020.
Two of his co-accused, Seán Hannaway and Edward O'Brien, have already been given leave on one issue only. It is whether evidence obtained by surveillance is admissible, given the claim that section 10 of the Criminal Justice (Surveillance) Act 2009 was not complied with. The court said the same point arises in Mr Nooney's case.
The Supreme Court said it is desirable that someone whose case could be decided by that point should be able to make submissions on it. He should not have to wait for, and be bound by, other people's appeals. But it said adding parties should not mean repeated arguments.
So leave is granted on that single question, which may be refined at case management.
The court attached tight conditions. Written submissions are limited to 4,000 words. Mr Nooney's are due by 7 October and the respondents' by 12 October. The parties must attend case management on 14 October. The court said they must also keep to "a strict and limited allocation of time for oral submission".
The Hannaway appeal is fixed for late October, and the court wants this appeal heard at the same time if possible.
The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice Dunne and Mr Justice Charleton.