localnews.ie

Reginald Carroll refused Supreme Court appeal in judicial review over dangerous driving trial

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court also refused him an extension of time, saying he wanted a further chance to make an application that had failed twice.

The Supreme Court has refused Reginald Carroll leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his judicial review proceedings, in a determination delivered on 7 February 2020. It also refused him an extension of time.

The proceedings concerned a decision by Judge Mary Fahy to set a hearing date for his trial on a dangerous driving charge and one other offence. Mr Carroll complained that he had been denied the right to elect trial by jury. The High Court gave him leave to seek to quash the decision.

He later applied to add grounds and further reliefs, including an injunction restraining gardaí from harassing him. Mr Justice Baker refused that on 31 May 2017, and the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 1 March 2019.

His application to the Supreme Court was made in January 2020, several months outside the 21-day limit. He said he had not understood the procedure. The Court said that even if that were excused, he had no arguable ground of general public importance.

It found that his case concerned only the application of well-established principles. It said the interests of justice test is not a catch-all, and that he simply wanted a further opportunity to make an application which had failed twice.

The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice MacMenamin and Justice Irvine.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal