Edward O'Brien has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on one point arising from his conviction for membership of an unlawful organisation. The determination was delivered on 21 September 2020. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed the application.
Mr O'Brien was one of five people convicted on 29 June 2018 after a trial before the Special Criminal Court that lasted fifty days. He was convicted of membership of an unlawful organisation. On 31 July 2018 he was sentenced to sixteen months in prison.
The Court of Appeal rejected all the appeals against conviction in a judgment delivered by Mr Justice Edwards on 6 February 2020. The appeal hearing took three days. The case centred on events on 7 and 8 August 2015 at a vacant rental property in Dublin. Gardaí investigating the IRA had obtained an authorisation under the Criminal Justice (Surveillance) Act 2009 and deployed audio devices there.
The prosecution relied mainly on the recordings, which it said showed an internal IRA inquiry. It also relied on the belief evidence of Detective Chief Superintendent Anthony Howard that Mr O'Brien was a member.
Mr O'Brien raised two broad questions. The first asked whether evidence consistent with membership of the IRA can support a chief superintendent's opinion of membership. The Supreme Court called this fact specific and said existing case law needs no further clarification.
The second concerns section 10(1) of the 2009 Act. It asks how far a distinction can be drawn between gathering a recording of voices, and storing it or accessing it, when deciding if surveillance evidence is admissible. The court said the law on that point had not been considered before. The prosecution said no recording evidence was advanced against him. The court nonetheless held that the issue warrants leave in his case. It refused leave on his other grounds.
The court noted that leave was already granted to his co-accused, Sean Hannaway. A case management hearing in that appeal is on 29 September 2020, and Mr O'Brien's case will be listed the same day before Ms Justice Baker.
The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice Dunne and Mr Justice Charleton.