Protégé International Group (Cyprus) Limited and Avalon International Management Inc have been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over a €1 million security for costs order in competition proceedings against Irish Distillers Limited. The determination was issued on 17 September 2020 by Chief Justice Frank Clarke and Justices Peter MacMenamin and Mary O’Malley.
Protégé does not dispute that it would be unable to pay Irish Distillers’ costs if the company successfully defended the proceedings and was awarded costs. The issue at the leave stage was whether Protégé could argue that its inability to pay was arguably due to the alleged wrongdoing by Irish Distillers.
The Court of Appeal had concluded that Protégé failed to meet the required standard on that point. The Supreme Court’s determination records that Protégé sought to argue that the established approach to security for costs should be adjusted, either generally or in cases raising European Union law rights.
The Supreme Court said the limited materials before it did not allow it to fairly decide whether Protégé was advancing a significantly different case from the one argued in the lower courts. It identified an issue of general public importance about whether existing security for costs jurisprudence may need to be reconsidered in light of the rights based arguments Protégé wished to make.
The Court granted leave to appeal, but did not decide the appeal on its merits. It directed that Irish Distillers may argue at the appeal hearing that some or all of Protégé’s proposed grounds should not be considered because, according to Irish Distillers, they were not advanced in the lower courts. A case management judge will decide whether that issue should be heard first or as part of the full appeal.
The Court also directed an early case management hearing to consider whether the appeal could be heard at or around the same time as a separate appeal concerning security for costs.