David Fennelly has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case about a complaint against the solicitor Adrian O'Doherty. The determination was delivered on 15 September 2020.
Mr Fennelly made the complaint to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal in September 2017. He said he was acting for his uncle, Thomas Fennelly, who had authorised him in a letter. The tribunal found no prima facie case of misconduct.
Mr Fennelly then appealed to the High Court in his own name. On 29 May 2019 Mr Justice Kelly ruled that he had no standing to bring the appeal. The Court of Appeal upheld that on 26 February 2020. It said the person who made the complaint was the person on whose behalf it was made, and that was Thomas Fennelly alone.
Mr Fennelly argued that he was an agent and that there was a public interest in letting an agent act for someone unable to pursue a complaint. He also wanted the rules clarified and a reference to the EU Court of Justice.
The Supreme Court said he had not engaged with the Court of Appeal's essential point. It said:
"The status contended for here, of an 'agent' entitled to proceed in his own name… has no basis in Irish law."
The court said no EU law issue arose, since the legislation was purely domestic. It found the constitutional criteria were not met.
The judges were Chief Justice Clarke, Ms Justice O'Malley and Ms Justice Baker.