Martin and Pauline Smith were refused leave by the Supreme Court to appeal the striking out of their appeal against a summary judgment in favour of Feniton Property Finance Limited. The determination was issued in 2019.
The Court of Appeal had struck out the appeal after the Smiths repeatedly failed to file books of appeal or written legal submissions, and found it frivolous, vexatious and bound to fail. The Supreme Court said the Smiths had not raised an issue of general public importance or shown that an appeal was needed in the interests of justice.
The Smiths had also challenged decisions concerning a request for particulars and a proposed trial on points of law. They raised questions about service of the proceedings and the affidavits relied on by Feniton. The Supreme Court said an appearance had been entered for them by their solicitor, so no issue about compliance with service rules could arise. It also said they could have objected to the affidavits at the High Court hearing, which they did not attend.
The Court refused leave to appeal; it did not decide a further appeal on its merits.