localnews.ie

Celyn Eadon granted Supreme Court appeal over murder conviction and intoxication direction

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will examine how juries should be told about intoxication and intent, and whether counsel's speeches can make up for gaps in a judge's charge.

The Supreme Court has granted Celyn Eadon leave to appeal his murder conviction. The determination was delivered on 16 April 2019. Mr Eadon applied after the Court of Appeal rejected his appeal on 15 May 2018.

Mr Eadon was nineteen when he killed his mother on 9 March 2011. He was charged with murder. The Director of Public Prosecutions did not accept his plea to manslaughter.

At trial he ran two defences. One was diminished responsibility, which the jury rejected. He is not pursuing it. The other concerned intoxication. The court was told he had abused alcohol and drugs since the age of thirteen.

The trial judge first told the jury that voluntary intoxication was no defence. He later re-charged them. He said intoxication was "part of the mix" in deciding whether a person could form the necessary intent.

The Court of Appeal (Edwards J., Mahon J. and Hedigan J.) had concerns about the original charge. It held that the re-charge was an adequate instruction. It also said counsel's speeches were "not wholly irrelevant" in judging a charge.

Mr Eadon raised two questions. The first was how juries should be directed on intoxication and intent. The second was whether counsel's speeches can supplement a deficient charge.

The Supreme Court said the law on intoxication and intent is not decisively clear. It found this to be a matter of general public importance. The second question would not qualify alone. It is closely linked to the first. Leave was granted on both.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal