The Supreme Court has refused Sean Farrell permission to appeal his conviction for a serious assault. The determination was delivered on 16 April 2019. Farrell applied after the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 28 June 2018.
A jury convicted him of causing serious harm contrary to section 4 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. He was sentenced to eight years. The jury acquitted him on charges relating to an earlier alleged incident.
The Court of Appeal had found that his trial lawyers took their decisions after extensive consultation with him. It rejected his claim that the verdict was inconsistent.
Farrell raised two points. He wanted the Supreme Court to set guidelines on how appeal courts judge the adequacy of a defendant's legal representation. He also asked whether witness statements admitted at trial can be given to the jury and kept by them.
The Supreme Court said his trial lawyers had made a deliberate decision on the second point. It found the Court of Appeal had not created a new or tougher test, and that the application did not engage with the proper criteria. The jury had also acquitted him on the two charges that rested only on those statements. Leave to appeal was refused.