The Supreme Court has granted Darren Fagan and his three children leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their case against Dublin City Council. The decision was delivered on 15 April 2019. The children are suing through Mr Fagan as their father and next friend.
The case concerns how a housing authority treats a separated parent who has access rights to children when assessing housing need. Under section 20(1) of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2009, a household can include two or more people who do not live together but who have a "reasonable requirement to live together".
The applicants say the council took account of factors it should not have when deciding whether that test was met. The High Court judgment, delivered on 19 November 2018, went against them. The council says the wording "in the opinion of the housing authority" gives it a reasonable discretion.
The Supreme Court said an issue of law arises about how far that discretion extends and which factors can properly be considered.
The application said as many as 800 people could be in a similar position. The council said only three or four had challenged its rulings. The court said that even if few have challenged, a ruling against the council could affect a reasonably large number of applicants. It also noted that different housing authorities may take different approaches.
The council argued that the applicants' interest is purely personal. The court said this does not stop an issue from being of general public importance.
It agreed to a direct appeal because the issue is a pure question of statutory interpretation. It said clarity is needed reasonably quickly. Leave was granted.