The Supreme Court refused Niall Quinn leave to appeal to it from the Court of Appeal in proceedings brought against him by ACC Loan Management DAC, in a determination delivered on 9 April 2019. Mr Quinn, the defendant, applied in person.
His appeal against a High Court decision had been transferred to the Court of Appeal. On 1 June 2018 that court made an unless order under which his appeal was dismissed because submissions directed to be filed were not filed in time. The Supreme Court described an unless order as giving a party guilty of significant procedural failure one final opportunity to mend their hand.
The Supreme Court noted that Mr Quinn had been directed on 24 February 2017 to deliver his submissions and did not do so. An extension was granted on 29 June 2017, and a further direction was made by agreement on 16 March 2018 requiring submissions by 8 June 2018. Each time they were not filed.
Mr Quinn argued that his constitutional right to a fair trial had been denied. The Supreme Court said parties must follow court procedures to exercise their rights, and that the other side is also entitled to a fair process.
It found no stateable basis for an appeal against the unless order and no issue of general public importance. Leave was refused, so it did not need to decide on the extension of time.