localnews.ie

Ignatius Forde refused Supreme Court appeal over committal warrant for unpaid excise duty fine

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had set aside a High Court decision that quashed the warrant used to jail him in March 2015 for not paying a €39,527.32 fine.

The Supreme Court has refused Ignatius Forde leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision about the committal warrant used to imprison him for not paying a fine for evasion of excise duty. The determination was delivered on 3 April 2019. Mr Forde was the applicant. The respondents were Judge Alice Doyle and the Courts Service, with the Director of Public Prosecutions as notice party.

Mr Forde pleaded guilty to evasion of excise duty under the Finance Act 2001. The value of the product was €26,351.55. The Circuit Court imposed the minimum fine permitted after the maximum fifty per cent mitigation, which was €39,527.32, with twelve months to pay. In default he faced one year in the Midlands Prison.

He did not pay. A committal warrant was issued and he was arrested on 5 March 2015. The High Court found the warrant had been issued by a Courts Service employee without the power to do so and quashed it. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set that decision aside.

Mr Forde argued that no judge considered whether a warrant should issue and that he had no chance to make representations first. The respondents said the warrant simply gave effect to the Circuit Court's final order.

The Supreme Court agreed with that view. It held that no further decision was needed once the payment period had passed, and that no point of general public importance arose. Leave to appeal was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal