localnews.ie

Sean Ó Conbhuí refused Supreme Court appeal over legal costs in child injury case

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

He wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal ruling in a dispute over the taxation of costs awarded against him after a child was injured on his land in 1996.

Sean Ó Conbhuí has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a dispute over legal costs that began with a personal injuries action. The decision was delivered on 29 March 2019.

The action concerned a five-year-old child who was injured while playing on Mr Ó Conbhuí's land in 1996. The child succeeded, and damages and costs were awarded against Mr Ó Conbhuí.

After protracted appeals, the Taxing Master ruled on those costs in 2013. Mr Ó Conbhuí objected, saying that he was an environmentalist and so entitled to the benefit of the Aarhus Convention.

He sought to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 9 March 2018, and applied for leave on 27 June 2018. He raised two issues: whether he was entitled to expert assistance at the Taxing Master hearing, and whether a person appointed under the Powers of Attorney Act 1996 could represent and assist him in the Court of Appeal.

The Supreme Court said he had not lodged the required copies of his papers and could have been refused on that ground alone. It examined the merits anyway and held that both points were “misconceived”.

The court said the Aarhus Convention has no application to proceedings of this nature. It added that the 1996 Act provides no right to be represented in court by a lay person.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal