localnews.ie

Judyta Rozmyslowicz case: Minister for Justice and Garda Commissioner refused Supreme Court appeal

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The State defendants wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal ruling that sent Ms Rozmyslowicz's claim over gardaí entering her home back to the High Court to assess damages.

The Supreme Court on 28 March 2019 refused leave to appeal to the Minister for Justice, Ireland, the Attorney General and the Garda Commissioner in a case taken by Judyta Rozmyslowicz.

The court said the defendants' arguments were “entirely misconceived”.

Ms Rozmyslowicz sued for damages for assault and breach of constitutional rights after gardaí entered her home without her consent. There was a warrant for the arrest of her partner, who was not in the house. She said an injury was caused when gardaí pushed in the door.

The High Court (Fullam J) dismissed her action on 13 April 2016. The Court of Appeal allowed her appeal on 17 August 2018 and sent the case back to the High Court to assess damages.

Hogan J, with Peart and Baker JJ agreeing, said the failure to put the defence case to her was “quite fundamental”.

The defendants applied for leave on 27 November 2018. They raised cross-examination and the “reasonable cause” test under section 6(1) of the Criminal Law Act 1997.

The Supreme Court said a party may not deliberately hold back its case in cross-examination to gain a tactical advantage. It said the Court of Appeal had applied ordinary logic and well-established principles.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal