localnews.ie

Brendan Kilty granted Supreme Court appeal in costs case involving District Court judge

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will hear when a District Court or Circuit Court judge can be made to pay costs after one of their orders is quashed on judicial review.

The Supreme Court has granted Brendan Kilty leave to appeal in his case against District Court judge Cormac Dunne. The determination was delivered on 25 January 2019. Campion Property Consultants Limited is a notice party.

Mr Kilty wants to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of 22 March 2018. That court refused him his costs of the appeal, even though he won a preliminary issue about the validity of a High Court costs order.

The case has a long history. In the High Court, Hedigan J made an unusual costs order against Judge Dunne after judicial review proceedings. Judge Dunne appealed to the Supreme Court. That court quashed the costs order and sent the matter back to the High Court. It did so because Judge Dunne had not been warned that costs might be awarded against him.

When the case returned, the High Court judge felt bound by the Supreme Court's order and made no order for costs. The Supreme Court said the High Court could have made a costs order, but only after looking at the facts and the law on judicial immunity. The Court of Appeal found that the "no order" approach was wrong.

The Court of Appeal judgment was given by Hogan J, sitting with Irvine and Stewart JJ. It set out the principles for costs against a District Court or Circuit Court judge. A judge is generally immune from costs. That immunity can be lifted only where the judge acted in bad faith. The judge must also take part in the proceedings to defend the order that was quashed. The Court of Appeal did not decide whether both tests must be met.

The Supreme Court said it is not a court for correcting errors. It found that a point of law of general public importance arises. It said when immunity from costs applies, and when it does not, are important issues for the administration of justice.

Leave covers three questions, which may be refined at case management. These are the test for judicial immunity from costs and whether the judge must be a party. They also include whether a judge can take part only on the issue of costs. The last is whether a judge can limit their participation to avoid liability for costs, even where the test for removing immunity may be met.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal