localnews.ie

Patricia O’Mahoney refused Supreme Court appeal over drink-driving trial

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

She had challenged the conduct of the District Court judge who convicted her of driving with alcohol over the permissible limit.

The Supreme Court on 25 March 2019 refused Patricia O’Mahoney leave to appeal in her judicial review case against District Judge Seamus Hughes.

Ms O’Mahoney had been convicted of driving while the concentration of alcohol in her breath exceeded the permissible limit.

She sought an order of certiorari, claiming the District Judge had breached fair procedures during her trial.

She also said his comments would lead an objective person to believe that he was biased.

The High Court (McDermott J) was not satisfied that anything the judge said was unfair or gave rise to bias.

The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Edwards J, agreed the trial was not unsatisfactory.

Her application to the Supreme Court, against the judgment of 30 July 2018, was made on 28 November 2018.

She argued that the Court of Appeal had changed the law on objective bias by considering the experience of counsel.

The Supreme Court did not accept that the Court of Appeal had altered the test for bias.

It said the court was simply describing the efficiency a judge may expect from an experienced practitioner.

It found no point of general public importance, and said both courts had examined the District Court transcript in detail.

She had a full hearing and appeal, it said, and could have appealed the criminal charge on its merits.

The court did not consider that a further appeal to the Supreme Court was necessary in the interests of justice.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal