Alan Gray has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in High Court proceedings brought against him by Simon Coyle. The decision was delivered on 4 March 2019.
Mr Gray, the defendant in those proceedings, sought leave to appeal from two orders of the Court of Appeal made on 4 October 2018. His application was made on 16 November 2018 and was within time.
The first order dismissed his appeal from a High Court ruling (Gilligan J) that refused reliefs he sought on discovery. It also confirmed that Mr Coyle had fully complied with a discovery order made on 13 July 2017. The second dismissed his appeal from a High Court order of 22 November 2017, which refused to strike out a notice of trial served by Mr Coyle.
The reasons for the Court of Appeal's orders are set out in a written judgment delivered by Irvine J on 28 September 2018.
The Supreme Court said Mr Gray had not identified any matter of general public importance. He had already had a full appeal hearing and a detailed written judgment, which applied well-established principles to the facts. It was therefore not necessary, in the interests of justice, to allow a further appeal.