Adrian and Patricia Flynn have been refused leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in a case brought by Leeds Building Society. The decision was delivered on 26 February 2019.
The society's claim is for possession of the Flynns' family home. It went first to the County Registrar and then to the Circuit Court, where Judge Karen Fergus heard it on 5 July 2016.
Mr Flynn had asked for an adjournment, a stay and discovery. The judge declined to hear issues she found irrelevant and refused discovery. She allowed the couple six weeks to lodge an amended defence and counterclaim.
The Flynns appealed to the High Court on Circuit, where Binchy J dismissed their motion in its entirety. He declined to refer a question to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
The Supreme Court said the couple were outside the 28-day time limit when they first tried to file. It said there were no arguable grounds of appeal. It noted that a High Court decision on a Circuit Court appeal is final and conclusive under the Courts of Justice Act 1936.
Even if an appeal were possible, the court said, they had not shown a matter of general public importance or that leave was in the interests of justice.