The Supreme Court has granted Barry McKelvey leave to appeal against Iarnród Éireann/Irish Rail, in a case about whether an employee facing a disciplinary hearing is entitled to legal representation. The determination was delivered on 25 February 2019.
Mr McKelvey applied for leave on 7 December 2018, within the time allowed. He wants to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of 31 October 2018 (Irvine J, with Whelan and Baker JJ concurring). That court had allowed an appeal by the company against a High Court order of 28 July 2017.
In the High Court, Murphy J had granted Mr McKelvey an interlocutory injunction. It restrained the company from starting a disciplinary hearing against him over alleged misconduct, notified to him on 8 May 2017, unless his claimed entitlement to legal representation was agreed.
Mr McKelvey had worked for the company since 1999 and had been an inspector since May 2013. He managed employees maintaining the Cork to Dublin railway line, and was issued fuel cards for refuelling company vehicles and machinery. A preliminary investigation into the use of fuel cards led the company to begin disciplinary proceedings.
The Supreme Court noted that High Court judgments conflict on the point. Eagar J in Lyons v Longford Westmeath Education and Training Board decided that legal representation was required, while McDermott J reached the opposite conclusion in N.M. v Limerick and Clare Education and Training Board. It also found a difference of approach between the High Court and the Court of Appeal in this case.
The company argued that no issue of general importance arose, because the Court of Appeal had followed the Supreme Court's decision in Burns v Governor of Castlerea Prison. The Supreme Court disagreed. It said the circumstances in which an employee or office holder, other than a prison officer, may claim legal representation in disciplinary proceedings raise an issue of general importance.
Leave was granted on the grounds in the application, which may be refined at case management.