localnews.ie

Brian and Christina Cannon granted Supreme Court appeal in Pepper Finance possession case

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple will take their case directly from the High Court over an order for possession, with the Supreme Court to hear it alongside Senior Money Mortgages v Gately.

The Supreme Court has granted Brian Cannon and Christina Cannon leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their dispute with Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) Designated Activity Company. The determination was delivered on 24 January 2019.

The Cannons, who are the defendants in the case, applied for leave to bypass the Court of Appeal. Pepper Finance is the plaintiff and opposed the application.

The case began with an order for possession made against the Cannons by a County Registrar on 19 January 2017. They did not appeal that order in time. The order was stayed until 1 August 2017. New solicitors then applied on 4 October 2017 for more time to appeal. The Circuit Court refused on 13 February 2018. The High Court dealt with the matter on appeal on 17 July 2018.

The High Court accepted there were arguable grounds of appeal. It found, however, that the Cannons had not formed a genuine intention to appeal within the time limit. The couple say that was wrong because the merits of their appeal were strong. They argue that, in a consumer contract, the court must look at the fairness of the terms under an EU directive, even on its own initiative. Pepper Finance strongly contests this.

The Supreme Court said the Cannons' argument did not itself raise a point of general importance. It granted leave for another reason. In a determination on 13 November 2018, in Senior Money Mortgages (Ireland) Ltd. v. Gately, the court had granted leave on how courts should decide whether to extend time to appeal. The court found the same issue arises here, and that it is a matter of general public importance.

Because the case comes from the High Court, the Cannons also had to show exceptional circumstances. They pointed to section 39 of the Courts of Justice Act 1936, which says High Court decisions on appeals of this kind are final. The court said this raises a question it has not yet settled. It will first decide whether an appeal lies to it at all and how that section applies. If it does, the court will consider what a judge should weigh when extending time to appeal.

The court will list the case for early case management so it can be heard alongside Senior Money Mortgages v. Gately. The Cannons must deliver written submissions within ten days. Pepper Finance then has ten days to reply.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal