The Supreme Court has granted Artur Daniel Celmer leave to appeal directly from the High Court against an order surrendering him to Poland. The decision was delivered on 20 February 2019.
Mr Celmer was the respondent in proceedings brought by the Minister for Justice and Equality under the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission took part as amicus curiae.
On 19 November 2018, Ms Justice Donnelly in the High Court ordered his surrender on foot of three European Arrest Warrants. She held that systemic and general deficiencies in the independence of the judiciary in Poland were not, of themselves, enough to show a real risk of a flagrant denial of justice. She certified a point of law of exceptional public importance to the Supreme Court.
Mr Celmer applied for leave to appeal on 10 December 2018. He argued that Poland's reforms had involved the forced retirement of hundreds of judges, and that judges were under pressure from a Minister for Justice who also acted as Public Prosecutor.
He also argued that the High Court had misread the ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union in the LM case. In his view, a breach of the right to an independent tribunal was, without more, a breach of the essence of the right to a fair trial. He said clarification from the Court of Justice might be needed, and that a direct appeal would limit further delay.
The Minister opposed the grant of leave. The Supreme Court noted that the question was whether the application met the constitutional test of general public importance, and said that it clearly did.
The court said the case required to be dealt with on a leapfrog basis, meaning directly from the High Court. Further directions on how the appeal will be conducted will be given at case management.