localnews.ie

Klaus Balz and Hannah Heubach granted Supreme Court appeal over windfarm noise guidelines

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple, who live about 635m from a proposed turbine, will appeal directly from the High Court over An Bord Pleanála's approval of the Cleanrath windfarm.

The Supreme Court has granted Klaus Balz and Hannah Heubach leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The case is about a windfarm permission granted by An Bord Pleanála. The determination was delivered on 14 February 2019.

The couple challenged the Board's decision to permit the windfarm. Cork County Council and Cleanrath Windfarm Limited are notice parties. The High Court upheld the permission in a judgment of 30 May 2018. Mr Balz and Ms Heubach then sought to bypass the Court of Appeal.

They live about 635m from the site of one of the proposed turbines. They told the Board that national wind energy guidelines from 2006 are out of date on turbine noise. Those guidelines say noise at 500m, with a limit of 45dB, is unlikely to be a significant problem. The couple sent scientific material and raised concern about a noise effect called amplitude modulation.

The Board's Inspector said the criticism of the guidelines was not a relevant planning consideration. He said amplitude modulation was the exception rather than the rule. The Board adopted his report and set a noise limit of 43dB. It did not adopt his recommendation to reduce the output of particular turbines if noise limits were exceeded.

The High Court judge held that the Board's duty to evaluate environmental effects covered only submissions of substance that bear on the effects of the development. He treated the claim that the guidelines were outdated as a policy matter.

The Supreme Court said the case raises issues of general public importance on how the Board should treat ministerial guidelines. The Board must have regard to them but is not obliged to follow them in every case.

The court drew a distinction. A submission that the guidelines do not suit a particular site relates directly to environmental effects. A submission that they are outdated everywhere may not. The question is how far the Board must consider such submissions.

The issues will be refined at the directions stage.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal