The Supreme Court has refused Patrick Nolan leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal order, in a determination delivered on 20 December 2019. The order he challenged had already given him what he had asked for, and more.
Mr Nolan is the defendant in a personal injuries claim brought by John Scott. Mr Scott claims damages for injuries allegedly caused by Mr Nolan's negligence as owner and operator of a motorcycle track.
On 30 July 2018 the High Court ordered that two motions on discovery and Mr Nolan's defence be dealt with by the trial judge. Later that day, without notice to him, part of that order was vacated at the plaintiff's request. Mr Nolan sought to appeal and needed an extension of time.
On 8 April 2019 the Court of Appeal decided there was no possibility the plaintiff could successfully oppose the appeal. It put Mr Nolan back in his earlier position, allowed him to deliver an amended defence and awarded him his expenses of the appeal.
The Supreme Court said an appeal against that order was unstateable and raised only a procedural issue in a private dispute. It said leave would not be in the interests of justice, since Mr Nolan had benefited significantly.
The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice Irvine and Justice Baker.