The Supreme Court has refused Mark Carlisle leave to appeal against his convictions for assault causing harm and violent disorder, in a determination delivered on 20 December 2019. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed the application.
The Court of Appeal had dismissed his appeal from the Circuit Criminal Court in an ex tempore ruling on 28 June 2019. The appeal rested on a single point of law arising from his trial, which took place over three days in July 2018.
The trial heard that Mark Conway was assaulted outside his home in Crumlin. His brother, Derek Conway, later identified Mr Carlisle at an informal identification parade, which gardaí arranged after Mr Carlisle refused to take part in a formal one. Mr Carlisle was the only person in the parade without shoes.
The Court of Appeal found the identification was based on facial recognition and that the lack of footwear was "sub-optimal" but did not affect it. Mr Carlisle argued that gardaí must observe a minimum standard of fairness in identification parades, whether formal or informal.
The Supreme Court said the law on informal parades is well established and his complaint concerned how it applied to the facts of this case. It found no evidence that the lack of footwear had a material part in the identification. It could identify no point of general public importance, and a further appeal was not required in the interests of justice.
The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice McKechnie and Justice Dunne.