The Supreme Court has refused Joseph Sheehan leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his case against Breccia Irish Agricultural Development Company and others. The determination is dated 6 December 2019.
Mr Sheehan wanted to challenge the role of the Commercial Court, although he had applied to have the proceedings admitted to it. The Court called it wholly untenable to raise such matters for the first time on a second appeal.
The other defendants are Blackrock Hospital Limited, George Duffy, Rosaleen Duffy and Tullycorbett Limited. Breccia opposed leave. The Court of Appeal ruling at issue was delivered on 31 July 2019.
Mr Sheehan relied on two sets of issues. One was how courts should grant or refuse interlocutory orders. The other concerned the role of the Commercial Court, or Commercial List.
The Supreme Court said the principles on interlocutory injunctions are well settled and were recently restated. It found the Court of Appeal had applied them to the facts, so no issue of general public importance arose.
It found no basis to say the interests of justice required a second appeal.
The case was dealt with urgently because the Court of Appeal had extended a stay on lifting an injunction only until 5.00pm on 29 November.