localnews.ie

David Cole granted Supreme Court appeal in claim against solicitor Bernadette Cahill

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal ruled that Mr Cole could not pursue his case once his co-plaintiff's claim was dismissed for delay and not appealed.

The Supreme Court has granted David Cole leave to appeal in his claim against solicitor Bernadette Cahill, trading as B.M. Cahill and Co. The determination was delivered on 27 November 2019. Leave was granted to Mr Cole, the first-named plaintiff, alone.

Mr Cole and Liam O'Mahony sued Ms Cahill together. Both had entered a commercial partnership with one other person. They state that the partners retained Ms Cahill as their solicitor.

They claimed she failed in the normal duties of a conveyancing solicitor. Those duties include checking the planning status of land being sold.

The proceedings were issued in 2012. On 19 July 2017 the High Court dismissed them for delay. Mr O'Mahony did not appeal, so he can no longer pursue the claim. Mr Cole did appeal.

The Court of Appeal decided against him on 22 July 2019. Its judges were Justices McGovern, Baker and McCarthy. They held that he could not maintain an action arising from the same cause of action. Justice Baker said the law cannot tolerate two judgments of the same court on the same cause of action. She called that a matter of certainty and finality in litigation, not a mere technicality.

Mr Cole argues that the old authorities relied on may be outdated. He says it is unfair that one partner's decision not to appeal binds the other. Some of the authorities date back to the 17th century.

The Supreme Court said the issues need clarification or consideration. It found they are a matter of general public importance and also raise a question under the interests of justice criterion.

Mr Cole applied for leave on 19 August 2019. The application was not in time. The Supreme Court has not yet decided the appeal itself. The panel was Justices O'Donnell, MacMenamin and Charleton.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal