localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear Waterford Credit Union appeal in J & E Davy discovery dispute

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will test when a court can refuse to order documents because a solicitor broke an implied undertaking in other proceedings.

Waterford Credit Union has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its case against J & E Davy. The decision was delivered on 26 November 2019. J & E Davy, the defendant, opposed leave.

The credit union is the plaintiff in the proceedings, which began in the High Court. It asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal against a Court of Appeal ruling of 5 June 2019. It applied for leave on 1 October 2019.

The dispute is about discovery, the process by which one side obtains documents from the other. The Supreme Court said the issue arises from the way discovery of a very narrow category of document was declined.

A party that receives documents through discovery is under an implied undertaking not to use them except for the litigation in which they were obtained. A court can release a party from that obligation in the right circumstances.

The Supreme Court said it appeared to have been accepted that the credit union's solicitor breached that undertaking in separate proceedings. The credit union was not a party to those proceedings.

It said the Court of Appeal considered that fact justified using its discretion to decline to order discovery of certain documents that would otherwise have met the criteria.

The Supreme Court said two questions of general public importance arise. The first is the precise scope of the obligations under an implied undertaking of this type. That bears on how serious the earlier breach should be taken to be.

The second is how far a court may use its discretion to refuse discovery because of an accepted earlier breach. That arises in particular where the breach was by a party's solicitor in other proceedings, not by the party itself.

The case management judge will make sure the grounds pursued in written submissions stay within the limits of the leave granted. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice Dunne and Justice O'Malley.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal