localnews.ie

Eve Doherty granted Supreme Court appeal over harassment conviction

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will decide whether harassment can include indirect harassment and what the word "beset" means in the 1997 Act, after a three-year sentence imposed in Dublin.

The Supreme Court granted Eve Doherty leave to appeal her harassment conviction in a determination delivered on 26 November 2019. The court will now hear her appeal against a decision of the Court of Appeal.

A jury in the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court convicted Ms Doherty of one count of harassment on 1 August 2017. She was sentenced to three years in prison and was acquitted of two other counts of making a false statement.

The Court of Appeal delivered its decision on 31 May 2019, given by Edwards J. It reduced her sentence, and the balance was suspended after she had served about twenty months.

Ms Doherty had been accused of a series of communications about the injured person, including letters to neighbours, flyers, a letter to the injured person's employer and emails to many others. She argues that this does not amount to harassment under section 10 of the Non Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. Her case rests mainly on the claim that the trial judge and the Court of Appeal were wrong to read the word "beset" in that section as covering her behaviour.

She also argues that the section does not cover "indirect harassment", and that the Supreme Court should clarify the point. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave. It said the courts rightly gave ordinary words their natural and ordinary meaning, so no issue of general public importance arises.

The Supreme Court disagreed and found that the case raises matters of general public importance. Those are whether harassment can include indirect harassment under the 1997 Act, and whether the Court of Appeal was right about the legal meaning of "beset". The court said clarity on both would have an impact beyond this case, so the constitutional threshold for leave to appeal was met.

The determination was made by Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. It decides only that the appeal may proceed, not the outcome of the appeal itself.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal