localnews.ie

Paul Sweeney: Supreme Court refuses appeal leave in injury case

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court declined to let Paul Sweeney appeal the Court of Appeal decision upholding dismissal of his personal injuries proceedings for want of prosecution.

Paul Sweeney’s application for leave to appeal in his personal injuries case was refused by the Supreme Court on 21 November 2019. The application concerned the dismissal of his proceedings for want of prosecution.

Sweeney sought to appeal the Court of Appeal decision affirming the High Court’s dismissal. He argued that he was entitled to a hearing within a reasonable time and that court-system delays and the defendants’ conduct had contributed to the delay. He also claimed the dismissal deprived him of access to the courts in a case involving serious personal injury.

The determination records that the Court of Appeal found changes in legal representation did not justify any part of the delay. It also noted the case had been in its list for about three years before Sweeney applied for directions. The first named defendant had died, and the Court of Appeal found that this had caused real prejudice.

The Supreme Court concluded that Sweeney could not succeed on the facts and that no point of law of general public importance arose. It refused leave; it did not decide a further appeal on its merits.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal