Bookfinders Limited has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its VAT dispute with the Revenue Commissioners. The Court said the Revenue measure at issue could apply in a reasonably significant number of cases.
The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 14 November 2019. Bookfinders was the applicant and the Revenue Commissioners were the respondent. Revenue opposed leave.
The case turns solely on the proper interpretation of Irish value added tax law. VAT is treated differently if a supply can be said to be of "food and drink". The main argument centred on whether that term should be read conjunctively or disjunctively.
The High Court, in a judgment reported as [2016] IEHC 569, found against Bookfinders. So did the Court of Appeal, in [2019] IECA 100, on 3 April 2019. The company applied for leave to appeal on 27 June 2019.
The parties disagreed on whether any real issue arises about how tax laws should be interpreted. The Supreme Court said some tax rules affect only a few people, but others apply widely and can affect many taxpayers and the public purse.
It said it could not rule out issues about the proper approach to interpreting tax measures, at least where those measures are the way Ireland has put EU obligations into law.
The Court said "an issue of general public importance does arise on a potential appeal in this case".
Leave was granted on narrow terms. The Court said the only issues are the questions of construction argued and decided in the Court of Appeal. Those are whether the High Court and the Court of Appeal interpreted the measures correctly, and so whether their answers in the case stated were right.
The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice MacMenamin and Justice Charleton.