The Supreme Court has refused leave to appeal to Maura Harrington, the second-named applicant in proceedings brought under sections 40, 40A and 40B of the Gas Act 1976, as amended. The determination was delivered on 14 November 2019 by Chief Justice Clarke, Justice Dunne and Justice Irvine.
The proceedings were brought by Martin Harrington, Maura Harrington, Monica Müller and Peter Sweetman against the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Ireland and the Attorney General. Shell E & P (Ireland) Limited was a notice party. The respondents opposed leave.
The order she wanted to appeal was a Court of Appeal ruling of 29 July 2019. The Supreme Court said that order refused an extension of time to appeal to the Court of Appeal from a High Court decision. The only question on any appeal would therefore be whether the Court of Appeal was right to refuse more time.
The Supreme Court said the underlying issues in the case could not form part of such an appeal. It found the Court of Appeal had applied the ordinary, well-established principles on extending time. No issue of general public importance had been shown, and the interests of justice test was not met.
The Supreme Court said the applicants had lost the right to pursue the proceedings because they failed to appeal in time, and for no other reason.