Stephen Burke has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a dangerous driving prosecution that raises his right to silence. The determination was issued on 12 November 2019.
Mr Burke faces two charges of dangerous driving arising from events on 13 January 2016. Garda James Reynolds called to his home and asked, under the Road Traffic Act 1961, whether he was the user of a motorcycle. The garda told him it would be an offence not to answer.
Mr Burke said several times that he was not the user. Some hours later he telephoned the garda to say that it was him. District Judge David Kennedy then sent a case stated to the High Court.
On 3 October 2018 the High Court (Binchy J.) held that an answer given under that section may be admitted in evidence. On 22 July 2019 the Court of Appeal (McCarthy J., with Birmingham P. and Whelan J.) agreed. It said the right to silence can be limited if the limit is proportionate, and the aim of road safety justified it.
Mr Burke argued that this wrongly infringes his constitutional right to silence and against self-incrimination. The Director of Public Prosecutions said well-established principles had been applied.
The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. agreed. It said the issue had been fully considered in the lower courts and nothing additional called for re-evaluation. Leave to appeal was refused.