localnews.ie

Patrick O'Brien refused Supreme Court appeal after settling back injury claim for €20,000

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said he had chosen to settle with legal advice, so the interests of justice did not favour letting him cross-examine the defendants now.

Patrick O'Brien has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case against Tony McCormack, John Cox and Michael Broderick. The determination was issued on 12 November 2019.

Mr O'Brien was injured on 28 January 2001 while employed by Galway County Council and attending a FÁS course. He said he hurt his back when required to throw large stones over a fence. His injury action was listed for hearing on 6 May 2006.

In pre-hearing talks he learned the three defendants would deny there were stones at the site. He considered they were not telling the truth, but he settled the action for €20,000 inclusive of costs.

He then sued the three, who he says were his supervisor and co-workers, for misrepresentation. On 10 July 2017 the High Court (Meenan J.) dismissed the claim as an attempt to re-litigate the settled action. The Court of Appeal (Costello J.) upheld that on 8 May 2019.

Mr O'Brien argued that the rules allowing a claim to be dismissed without a full hearing are unfair, and that he was denied the chance to cross-examine the defendants.

The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. rejected both points. It said the dismissal power is well established and he did not challenge the rules. He had passed up the chance to test their evidence when he settled with legal advice.

The court found no arguable ground of appeal. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal