localnews.ie

Aditya Sharma refused Supreme Court appeal over 2009 driving without insurance conviction

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said judicial review cannot be used to obtain a third opportunity to resolve an issue after a first appeal has failed.

Aditya Sharma has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a Court of Appeal decision of 19 February 2019. The determination, issued on 12 November 2019, concerns his conviction for driving without insurance on 1 May 2009.

The District Court convicted him of road traffic offences on 10 June 2010. For the insurance offence he was disqualified from driving for twelve months and fined €300.

The Circuit Court heard his appeals on 29 June 2011. By an order of 18 April 2012 it affirmed that conviction, and the disqualification took effect from 29 June 2011.

Mr Sharma then sought leave to bring judicial review to quash the Circuit Court order. The High Court (McGovern J.) refused leave on 25 June 2012. On 19 February 2019 the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal, with Birmingham P. saying he had reached "the end of the road".

Mr Sharma argued that the interests of justice required that he be allowed to have the conviction removed from his licence, because he was insured. He did not argue that the case raised a matter of general public importance.

The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. held that judicial review cannot give a litigant disgruntled by an appeal a third opportunity to have an issue resolved. It said he had shown no irregularity or want of procedural fairness.

The court also noted that the disqualification has long since expired. Leave to appeal was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal