localnews.ie

Alan McNamara granted Supreme Court appeal over provocation defence in murder conviction

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the law on provocation is not settled, including whether the defence can apply when an accused kills someone other than the person who provoked him.

The Supreme Court granted Alan McNamara leave on 19 November 2019 to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision in his murder case. The appeal will examine the legal defence of provocation.

Mr McNamara was convicted of murder on 31 July 2018. During the trial McDermott J. ruled that provocation should not be left for the jury to consider. Birmingham P. upheld that reasoning in the Court of Appeal on 28 May 2019.

The court recorded that in June 2015 Mr McNamara was assaulted outside a public house by members of a rival motorcycle club, who forcibly took his jacket and insignia. Some people later appeared at or near his home and made a threat.

The next day he went to the other club's premises with a sawn-off shotgun. He encountered Andrew O'Donoghue and fired a shot at close range, killing him. The court said there does not seem to be evidence that Mr O'Donoghue was part of the original incident.

Mr McNamara argues that provocation should have been left to the jury, although about 16 hours had passed. The Director of Public Prosecutions says the decision was correct and the law is settled.

The Supreme Court panel of O'Donnell J., McKechnie J. and Charleton J. disagreed that the law is settled. It listed points for consideration, including whether the defence applies where the accused kills someone other than the original provoker, and whether background circumstances can found the defence.

It also pointed to whether the defence has an objective element, and to the role of the trial judge and the burden of adducing evidence.

Leave to appeal was granted. The points can be refined at case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal