localnews.ie

Bank of Ireland wins appeal leave over liquidator costs

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court granted Eteams International Limited and its liquidator leave to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision that the liquidator should pay the bank’s appeal costs.

Eteams International Limited and its liquidator, Anthony Fitzpatrick, have been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal a costs order arising from a dispute over the company’s debts and an invoice discounting agreement, in a determination dated 23 October 2019.

The appeal concerns the Court of Appeal’s decision that Mr Fitzpatrick should personally pay the Bank of Ireland’s costs of the appeal. The Supreme Court granted leave on that issue, finding it raised a point of law that may be important beyond the particular case.

The underlying proceedings concerned whether an agreement between the company and the bank transferred ownership of the company’s debts to the bank, or created a charge over them that required registration under the Companies Act 1963. The High Court concluded that the agreement was a debt purchase agreement and did not require registration. It ordered the company to provide the bank with debts collected and relevant documents and information, and made a costs order against the company.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the company’s appeal from that decision. It also accepted the bank’s argument that the liquidator, rather than the company, was the proper applicant in the directions proceedings under section 280 of the Companies Act 1963, and ordered him to pay the bank’s appeal costs.

The Supreme Court refused leave to appeal the ruling on the agreement’s character. It said the High Court had reviewed a consistent line of UK authorities in a similar statutory and commercial context, and the Court of Appeal had affirmed that decision. The Court considered the law settled on that point.

The determination records the Supreme Court panel as O’Donnell, MacMenamin and Charleton JJ. Granting leave allows an appeal to proceed on the costs issue; it does not decide that issue on its merits.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal