Patrick O’Brien’s application for leave to appeal over alleged solicitor misconduct was refused by the Supreme Court on 15 October 2019. The Court declined leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal’s decision, which had dismissed his appeal from the High Court. The Supreme Court did not decide the underlying misconduct allegation on its merits.
O’Brien had sought an inquiry into Sheenagh McCarthy’s conduct at a 2005 oral hearing concerning his claim for occupational injuries benefit. He alleged that medical evidence had been withheld. The Solicitors’ Disciplinary Tribunal found no prima facie case of misconduct in 2014. The High Court found no grounds for a finding of misconduct, and the Court of Appeal upheld that decision in 2019.
The Supreme Court said the application disclosed no matter of general public importance and no indication that either lower court had erred. It also found no issue that it was in the interests of justice for it to hear. The Court of Appeal had declined to admit further evidence, a decision the Supreme Court said it was entitled to make.