Three companies trading as RAC Contractors and RAC Eire Partnership have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against an order to provide security for costs. The determination was issued on 14 October 2019.
The companies, Rosas Construtores S.A., Construcoes Gabriel As Couto S.A. and Empresa Deconstrucoes Amandio Carvalho S.A., must therefore comply with a Court of Appeal order of 31 May 2019 (Irvine J.). It required security of €278,228 for the plaintiffs' costs of their appeals. The plaintiffs, led by Carlos Manuel Miranda, had won in the High Court.
The companies were accepted to be solvent. But the plaintiffs pointed out that they had failed to satisfy six orders of the High Court and Court of Appeal to pay damages and taxed costs. Irvine J. said the unexplained, persistent refusal to pay amounted to extraordinary circumstances.
The companies argued that the ruling fundamentally changed the law on security for costs. The Supreme Court panel of O'Donnell J., McKechnie J. and Charleton J. disagreed.
It said the order applied a long-standing rule allowing security for costs of an appeal in special circumstances. Such circumstances are unlikely to affect many future cases.
Leave to appeal was refused.