localnews.ie

Rory Ennis granted Supreme Court appeal in AIB case over Kildare land

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will examine when an appeal court should allow new arguments on appeal, in a case where a lay litigant may get free legal representation.

The Supreme Court granted Rory Ennis leave on 14 October 2019 to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in a possession case brought by Allied Irish Banks plc. The case concerns lands in County Kildare.

On 27 June 2016 the High Court (Baker J.) ordered Mr Ennis to deliver up possession of the lands. The Court of Appeal (Whelan, Costello and Kennedy JJ.) dismissed his appeal on 24 January 2019. He applied for leave on 18 February 2019.

Mr Ennis represents himself. He accepts that his defence in the High Court was inadequate. In the Court of Appeal he was allowed to bring fresh evidence and to argue new points, including a claim under the Consumer Credit Act 1995.

His complaint is that he sold part of the lands for €135,000 and used €62,500 to reduce his debt. He expected this to cut his monthly repayments by €400. He later signed a facility letter that shortened the repayment period by five years and cut repayments by €20 a month.

The Court of Appeal expressed sympathy but decided it should not entertain the new arguments. The Supreme Court panel of O'Donnell J., McKechnie J. and MacMenamin J. said the new matters did not appear particularly strong or meritorious.

It still found a point of some general importance. This is how an appeal court should approach a request to argue additional grounds of appeal, particularly in applications for interlocutory judgment. The court noted a possible tension with the test for admitting fresh evidence.

Leave was granted on that issue. Case management will decide whether the appeal should also address additional grounds. The court said Mr Ennis may benefit from a voluntary scheme under which a solicitor and counsel can be assigned to him.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal